MINUTES
OXFORD TOWNSHIP
LAND USE BOARD MEETING
NOVEMBER 14, 2005
Chairman D. Ischinger called the
meeting to order at 7:30 p.m.
ADEQUATE NOTICE was given as
follows: Notice was sent to the Star
Gazette and Express Times. Notice was posted on the
Municipal bulletin
Board in the Township Administration building in
Oxford Township,
New Jersey, and notice was filed with the Township
Clerk.
ROLL CALL:
Members Present: Mr. Ischinger, Dr. Yeager, Ms.
Smorzaniuk, Mayor Lazorisak,
Mr. Rosenberg, Mr. Cratch, Mr. Calabrese, Ms.
Ciaburri, Mr. Dresser
Members Absent: Ms. Accetturo
Also Present: Attorney M. Garofalo, Engineer W.
Gleva
COMMUNICATIONS: A list will be
provided to the Land Use Board members.
Action Required:
1. Angelo Accetturo – 34 Axford Avenue – Request for
an extension for a
Minor Subdivision application for Block 37, Lot 34.
Resolution adopted on
February 14, 2005. The applicant was represented by
Attorney M. Lavery.
A motion to grant Mr. Accetturo a 60-day extension
on his Minor Subdivision
application was made by Mayor Lazorisak, seconded by
Mr. Ischinger, all ayes,
motion carried.
MINUTES: Minutes of the October 3,
2005 meeting will be tabled until the
December 12, 2005 meeting.
ZONING OFFICER’S REPORT: September
and October zoning reports.
September zoning report:
Five permits issued, zero permits denied, multiple
calls and questions.
October zoning report:
Two permits issued, zero permits denied, multiple
calls and questions.
COMPLETENESS ITEMS:
1. Phillip & Donna Martin – Second Completeness
review for a Variance
application for Block 2, Lot 13.01 located at 200A
Jonestown Road.
Attorney M. Garofalo stated the application should
be deemed
incomplete and the applicant should return on
December 12, 2005 for
completeness and public hearing. A motion to deem
the application
incomplete was made by Mr. Ischinger, seconded by
Mr. Rosenberg,
Vote: Ischinger, Rosenberg, Yeager, Smorzaniuk,
Lazorisak, Cratch,
Calabrese, Ciaburri, Dresser – Ayes, 0 – Nay, 0 –
Abstain, motion carried.
DISCUSSION & PUBLIC HEARING ITEMS:
1. Wall Street Partners LLC/ Samir Elbassiouny –
Public Hearing for a Site
Plan and Minor Subdivision application with Variance
relief for Block 6,
Lot 4 located on Wall Street. This application has
been carried from the
October 3, 2005 meeting with no testimony given. The
applicant was
Represented by Attorney M. Lavery and Engineer R.
Callizzoni.
Applicant Samir Elbassiouny briefly reviewed the
architectural drawings
including the façade and the elevation. Mr.
Elbassiouny stated the building
would be stone on the bottom half and siding on the
top, the building would
appear more similar to Shippen Manor.
Mayor Lazorisak stated the elevations should be
clearly marked and depicted
what would be on the façade. Mr. Elbassiouny stated
if he brought in an
architect it would cost him another three, four or
five thousand dollars.
Mr. Elbassiouny stated he would rather invest the
five thousand dollars in
better windows but he would take recommendations
from the Board.
Mr. Rosenberg stated he would rather see the money
spent on windows but
if he doesn’t rely on what he is testifying to then
he is in violation of what
we are going to memorialize. Mayor Lazorisak stated
he would hate to start
a protocol like this. Chairman Ischinger stated as
long as the Board has some
re-course. Engineer Mr. Gleva stated his office has
not seen those plans, the
plans would need to be submitted to review the plans
with the ordinance.
Mayor Lazorisak stated at the end of the application
the Board should have
finalized set of elevation architectural drawings
before the resolution.
Attorney M. Garofalo swore in the applicant and
witnesses.
Mr. Elbassiouny reviewed the current uses of the
property and adjoining
properties. Exhibit A-1 Original building & A-2
Finalized building,
A-3 Drawing showing front façade of the building.
Mr. Elbassiouny testified
there would be eight classrooms, shown on A-4, the
entrance would be from
the rear but would also include a front entrance.
There would be one bathroom
for every two classrooms, the teachers will have
their own bathroom.
Mr. Elbassiouny stated his wife will is an
elementary school teacher will be
running the daycare center, the center will be open
from 5:00 or 6:00 a.m. to
6:00 p.m. at night. Mr. Elbassiouny stated there
would be a total of ten
staff members. Mr. Elbassiouny reviewed A-5 which
shows the four upper
level one bedroom apartments. Chairman Ischinger
asked what about security
for the daycare center, Mr. Elbassiouny stated there
would be ID and cameras
in there. Mayor Lazorisak asked what the maximum
number of children would
be allowed, Mr. Elbassiouny stated seventy age
infant to kindergarten. Mayor
Lazorisak asked for a plan for an emergency. Mr.
Elbassiouny stated once he has
approvals from the Board everything will have to be
reviewed by the State
which includes emergency, Mr. Elbassiouny stated
there would be steel stairs,
a hardwired sprinkler system, fire escapes. Engineer
R. Pelizzoni addressed the
proposed enclosed playground area in the rear of the
building which will be
surrounded by a four foot high chain link fence. Mr.
Pelizzoni stated most of the
conditions are pre-existing regarding the setbacks.
Mayor Lazorisak
requested parking be addressed and traffic patterns.
Ms. Ciaburri
stated she has concern over kids in the road at
afternoon pick up, children
going for haircuts, people don’t pay attention when
they are in a hurry.
Mr. Pelizzoni stated there would be drop off zones
in the back for the parents.
Mr. Pelizzoni reviewed the ingress and egress to the
building.
Chairman Ischinger asked what if there is a
Christmas party for the kids.
Mayor Lazorisak asked what would be the worse case
scenario for the traffic
pattern and could we review the traffic design by
Finelli. Engineer
M. Gleva stated the traffic pattern was discussed
and there is a comment
on the report, but there is not a detailed analysis.
Attorney M. Garofalo suggested a traffic engineer
present testimony.
Mayor Lazorisak stated that the Board Engineer
hasn’t really addressed traffic
and must be addressed by our Engineer and a review
of the downtown plan.
Attorney M. Lavery stated there will always be a
parking issue there but the
use is less intense because its staggered.
Mayor Lazorisak stated the Township Committee will
have to allocate parking
spaces for the apartments downtown.
Attorney M. Lavery reviewed the proposed variances
and the pre-existing
conditions with Mr. Pelizzoni.
PUBLIC COMMENT:
Mr. Dan Marcmann, VP of Skylands Bank stated he has
items of concern
from Mr. Finelli’s report regarding parking and
traffic flow. Mr. Marcmann
stated the Bank does not wish to share parking and
does not wish waivers
to be granted. Attorney M. Garofalo stated the
waivers have been already
granted for completeness.
Chairman Ischinger and Mayor Lazorisak agreed Mr.
Finelli must review the
traffic design and address the traffic and parking
concerns.
Joan Mulligan of 25 Washington Avenue
Ms. Mulligan stated at one time every building on
Wall St. had a business and
the parking worked out. Ms. Mulligan asked for
lighting to be addressed.
Chairman Ischinger agreed, the area is very dark and
requires additional lighting.
Attorney M. Lavery concluded his witnesses
testimony. Attorney M. Garofalo
reviewed the Board’s options on the application and
the variances.
A motion to grant bulk variance approval was made by
Mr. Cratch, seconded
By Ms. Smorzaniuk, Vote: Cratch, Smorzaniuk,
Ischinger, Yeager, Rosenberg,
Calabrese, Ciaburri, Dresser – Ayes, Lazorisak –
Nay, 0 – Abstain, motion
carried. Engineer M. Gleva stated at a minimum the
plans should be submitted to
emergency services for review. Applicant, Mr.
Elbassiouny asked the Board
to consider not waiting another month for site plan
approval. Attorney M.
Garofalo addressed another possible problem which
may arise by granting
approval tonight.
A motion to grant Site Plan approval pending the
satisfaction of the Land Use
Board Engineer’s traffic review was made by Mr.
Rosenberg, seconded by
Ms. Smorzaniuk, Vote: Rosenberg, Smorzaniuk,
Ischinger, Yeager, Cratch,
Calabrese, Dresser – Ayes, Lazorisak, Ciaburri –
Nay, 0 – Abstain, motion
carried.
2. Organic Aggregates, Inc. – Public Hearing for a
Site Plan application for
Block 26, Lot 87 located on Quarry Road. This
application has been carried
from the October 3, 2005 meeting with no testimony
given. Dr. Yeager
stepped down for this application. The applicant was
represented by
Attorney D. Morrow and Engineer T. Bayer. Engineer
M. Finelli briefly
reviewed the application. Attorney M. Garofalo
stated the application was
a nice ratable with minimal noise, Mr. Garofalo
stated the use was permitted
in the light industrial zone. Attorney M. Garofalo
swore in witnesses J. Popinko
and Engineer T. Bayer. Engineer T. Bayer reviewed
the operation.
The applicant stated they were here seeking site
plan approval to comply with
the DEP regulations.
Mr. Popinko reviewed the glass sand and aggregate
operations and storage.
Mr. Popinko stated that the operation is considered
a manufacturing operation
but is exempt from the solid waste regulations of
the DEP.
Mr. Popinko reviewed co-products and determinations
to be renewed
in July 2006. Mr. Cratch asked if the separation has
been changed, Mr. Popinko
said there hasn’t been any change. Mayor Lazorisak
asked Mr. Bayer to
go into more detail regarding the samples. Mr.
Popinko stated the DEP issues
a co-product determination when the samples are
approved. Mr. Bayer stated
there would access through the County road not
Township. Mr. Bayer stated
there would be very minimal odors from the product.
Engineer T. Bayer
reviewed Mr. Finelli’s technical review including
landscaping and site triangles,
proposed shrubs for screening evergreen and fir
trees. Mr. Bayer stated the
storage areas have been delineated on the site plan,
the materials are moved on
the site with a front end loader. Mr. Bayer stated
he would provide a construction
detail per Mr. Finelli’s request and show the
current stockpiles on the plan.
Mr. Bayer stated there was no current proposal for
lighting the business will be
operating during daylight hours but security
lighting would be provided.
Mr. Bayer stated the open storage and display did
not apply. Mr. Bayer
reviewed the buffer strip and why it doesn’t apply.
Mayor Lazorisak requested
copies of the DEP letters be supplied to the
Township Engineer. Similar to the
previous application deed restrictions will also
apply to this application.
Attorney M. Garofalo reviewed the statements
regarding deed restrictions.
PUBLIC COMMENT:
Committeeman A. Accetturo stated the deed
restrictions should be reviewed by
Attorney M. Garofalo. A motion to grant Preliminary
Site Plan approval was
made by Mr. Rosenberg, seconded by Mayor Lazorisak,
Vote: Rosenberg,
Lazorisak, Ischinger, Smorzaniuk, Cratch, Calabrese,
Ciaburri, Dresser – Ayes,
0 – Nay, 0 – Abstain, motion carried.
3. John & Jacqueline Edmonds –
Resolution for a Minor Subdivision
application with Variance relief for Block 24, Lot
63 located at 111 Belvidere
Ave., Oxford NJ. This application received approval
on October 3, 2005.
A motion to approve was made by Dr. Yeager, seconded
by Ms. Ciaburri,
Vote: Yeager, Ciaburri, Dresser, Ischinger,
Lazorisak, Rosenberg, Smorzaniuk
- Ayes, 0 – Nay, 0 – Abstain, motion carried.
PUBLIC COMMENT: No further public
comment was offered.
MAYOR’S REPORT: No report given.
VOUCHERS:
A motion to approve vouchers submitted for November
14, 2005 was made
By Ms. Smorzaniuk, seconded by Mr. Dresser, all ayes
motion carried.
ADJOURNMENT: 12:05 a.m.
With no further business before the Board and no
public comment offered the
meeting was adjourned.
Respectfully Submitted,
Margaret Housman, Secretary
Oxford Township LUB |